The Big Banks are your MOST expensive mortgage option.

Sabeena Bubber • March 12, 2019

If you qualify for mortgage financing at any of Canada’s big six banks, chances are you will be eligible somewhere else as well. And you could be paying A LOT less interest and have a more flexible mortgage.

Recent analysis shows that in 2018 having a mortgage (dealing directly with) RBC, TD, BMO, Scotiabank, CIBC, or the National Bank of Canada was consistently the most expensive option for Canadians. Even the lowest rates of the big six were always costlier than the lowest rates from smaller lenders.

For example, when RBC lowered its 5-year fixed rate to 3.74%, consumers on that rate would pay $2,560 per month on a $500,000 mortgage (25-year amortization with 20% down to avoid paying CMHC insurance). The best available rate at a monoline lender at the same time was 3.23%, saving borrowers $134 per month (with a payment of $2,426). When you roll this savings out over the lifetime of the mortgage, you’re looking at a savings of $40,200.

But let’s not just compare mortgages by their rate, (which is like comparing cars based on their colour alone). When you look at all the mortgage features and compare the big 6 banks to mono-line lenders, you find that the smaller lenders have the edge here as well.

Without getting too heavy into the details, understanding the cost to break your mortgage is the single most important decision you should make when considering a mortgage. Your mortgage will either have a three months interest penalty, or what’s called an Interest Rate Differential Penalty (IRD).

Unfortunately, there is no standardization in how IRDs are calculated in Canada, this leaves each institution to create their formulas on how to charge you extra money. One thing is for sure, big banks are fantastic at making money, as such the cost to break a mortgage at a big bank is considerably more than at a smaller lender.

Another reason the big banks are your most expensive mortgage option is that they really don’t provide you with real mortgage options at all. They only sell their own products. 

When you deal with a single financial institution, you are dealing with a banker, who is paid by the bank, to make the bank money. This person doesn’t have your best interests in mind, they have sales goals to meet and will advise you accordingly.

Alternatively, when you work with an independent mortgage professional, you can choose mortgage options from many financial institutions. Also, you receive financial advice that is impartial and not tied to a single institution's bottom line, so you can stay clear of lenders with astronomical payout penalties.

If you have a mortgage at one of Canada’s big banks, and it’s up for renewal within the next couple of years, please consider connecting with me so that we can put together a plan to save you money on your next mortgage.

I can represent you to many lenders who have lower rates and better mortgage options than any of the big six banks.

Let’s talk. Sabeena Bubber 604-862- 8526 or visit sabeenabubber.ca .

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT POSTS

Sabeena and family at Canadian Mortgage Hall Of Fame

A Night I’ll Always Carry With Me

By Sabeena Bubber • October 24, 2026
Sabeena Bubber reflects on her Canadian Mortgage Hall of Fame induction, the journey behind it, and the people who made this meaningful milestone possible.

How Property Type and Condition Influence Mortgage Financing

By Sabeena Bubber • October 21, 2026
Why the Property Matters When You’re Qualifying for a Mortgage When qualifying for a mortgage, lenders typically look at four core areas: Income Credit Down payment or equity The property itself Most buyers focus heavily on income, credit, and savings—and for good reason. But even if those boxes are checked, the property can still determine whether a mortgage is approved. Why Lenders Care About the Property From a lender’s perspective, the property is the collateral for the mortgage. In the unlikely event of default, they need to know the home can be sold quickly and at fair market value to recover their funds. Because of this, lenders are careful about the condition, value, and marketability of any property they finance. Homes that are in poor repair, unconventional, or overpriced can raise red flags—even when the borrower is well qualified. Appraisals Are Always Part of the Process Every mortgage requires an appraisal to confirm value. Insured mortgages (through CMHC, Sagen, or Canada Guaranty) often use an automated valuation model completed online. Conventional mortgages typically require a full, on-site appraisal by a certified appraiser. This appraisal is not optional and happens after an offer is accepted—not at the pre-approval stage. Why Pre-Approvals Aren’t a Guarantee A pre-approval is a great first step, but it only assesses you, not the property. Once you’ve made an offer, the lender must approve the specific home you’re buying. Understanding this upfront helps avoid surprises and confusion later in the process. The Risk of Buying Without a Financing Condition In competitive markets, buyers sometimes remove financing conditions to strengthen their offer. However, this comes with risk. If the appraisal comes back low—or the lender is concerned about the property’s condition—you could be denied financing after the offer is firm. In that scenario, your deposit may be at risk. Buying a Home That Needs Work If you’re considering a property that isn’t in perfect condition, there are solutions. A purchase plus improvements program allows you to buy a home and include renovation costs in your mortgage. The process is structured and requires planning, but it can be an excellent way to turn a fixer-upper into a great long-term investment. Final Thoughts Mortgage approval isn’t based solely on your finances—the property matters just as much. Knowing this ahead of time helps you make smarter offers, reduce risk, and plan more effectively. If you’re buying a property that needs work or want clarity on how a lender may view a specific home, feel free to reach out. I’d be happy to walk you through your options and help you plan with confidence.

How to Maximize Your Mortgage Renewal Opportunity

By Sabeena Bubber • October 14, 2026
Your Lender Is Not Obligated to Renew Your Mortgage Many homeowners assume that if they’ve made every mortgage payment on time, their lender is automatically required to renew their mortgage at the end of the term. That’s a common belief—but it isn’t true. When you sign a mortgage, you’re agreeing to a contract for a specific term . Once that term ends, the lender has the legal right to either renew the mortgage or call the loan . There is no obligation to offer a renewal. In practice, most lenders do renew mortgages—but certain situations can prevent that from happening. Reasons a Lender May Decline to Renew A lender may choose not to renew if: Mortgage payments were missed during the term A bankruptcy or consumer proposal has occurred There is a separation or divorce Employment or income has changed A borrower on the mortgage has passed away The lender no longer prefers the property’s location or market The lender is no longer licensed to lend in Canada Even one of these factors can change how a lender views the risk. Why This Matters Because renewal is not guaranteed, waiting until the last minute can put you in a difficult position. Understanding this reality early gives you time and control. How to Protect Yourself at Renewal The best approach is to be proactive. Ideally, you should begin reviewing your options 120 days before your mortgage term ends . This gives you enough time to explore alternatives and make informed decisions—rather than reacting under pressure. Even if your current lender offers a renewal, that’s just one option , not automatically the best one. The lender that was right for you years ago may no longer offer the most competitive rate, terms, or flexibility today. The goal at renewal isn’t convenience—it’s reducing your total cost of borrowing and choosing terms that align with your current situation. Why Work With an Independent Mortgage Professional Working with an independent mortgage professional ensures someone is advocating for you , not the lender. Instead of being limited to one set of products, you can compare options across multiple lenders and choose the solution that best protects your interests. Final Thoughts Whether your lender is offering a renewal or not, the smartest move is to review all your options before signing anything. If your mortgage is coming up for renewal—or if you want to plan ahead—feel free to connect anytime. I’d be happy to help you protect your options and make a confident decision.