Private Mortgage Investing, What you need to know?  Is it for you?

Sabeena Bubber • November 21, 2016

This is a special article published to my blog, written by Dean Larson, COO of Northern Alliance Financial. If you have any questions, please contact me directly.  

Increasingly, Canadians are becoming more and more aware that traditional investments may not be their only or even best options anymore.   The average Canadian, particularly Gen Xers or Millennials, are less likely to blindly follow traditional investment advice from a bank, or even from that family friend, a financial planner, or insurance advisor.

The question is - what has changed?   Have people’s expectations changed?   Have investments changed?   Have our available options changed?   The answer to all of these is a resounding “YES!”   Historically, banks and insurance companies have created investment opportunities.   Consumer-focused investments included life insurance, bonds, mutual funds and other similar products with the object of providing neatly packaged, relatively conservative, accessible investments to the masses.

Today, the public has access to a myriad of investment options that would have once been relegated exclusively to very wealthy individuals or institutional investors.   One of these investment options is mortgage lending.

The mortgage market today can be divided primarily into the following categories:

‘Prime’ or ‘A’ Mortgages – These mortgages are for typical mortgage borrowers with good credit, regular employment and a down payment.   These low-rate mortgages are obtained primarily from banks, credit unions and monoline mortgage lenders (non bank lenders who are specifically in the mortgage business, and often funded by other big banks).

‘Alt A’ or ‘B’ Mortgages –.   These mortgages are designed for borrowers that fall just outside of standard mortgage qualification guidelines.   Some borrowers cannot prove self-employment income in standard ways, or provide non-standard down-payments, or have past credit blemishes. Institutional lenders and banks that are specifically focused on this type of lending typically have higher interest rates than ‘A’ lenders.

Private Mortgages – Private mortgages themselves can be divided up into two categories:

  1. Syndication / Direct mortgage- This is where an individual lends money to a specific borrower on a specific property.   The advantage to a lender is that they can dictate their return for that specific mortgage.   The disadvantage to the lender is that there are too many eggs in one basket, and if something goes wrong with that specific borrower or property, the individual that lent the money absorbs all the losses. Investment diversification is wise, even with mortgages.
  1. Mortgage Funds - These funds can take a variety of forms.   The technical term from a regulatory standpoint is “Mortgage Investment Entity”.   These funds can take form in a variety of structures such as   ‘mortgage investment corporation’, ‘mutual fund trust’, or even partnerships and corporations.   The differences between them largely have to do with regulatory and tax implications, although one could argue that a more regulated fund with greater checks and balances, further protects the investor. 

Advantages for an investor to invest through a fund rather than direct to the borrower include:

i) The investor’s money is in a pool with other investors and invested in a pool of mortgages.   So if a mortgage were to default and realize losses, the loss to fund is dispersed among the investors.   Typically a well-managed fund can have defaults without individual investors being aware, or suffering significant impact on their returns.

ii) The investor is not concerned about managing the investment, or regulatory issues.   The investor is not responsible for any reporting to the borrower, or any managing of defaults, or the payout of the mortgage.

So is it for me?   What’s the catch?   What’s the risk?

Mortgage funds create a great opportunity for an investor to earn consistent above-average returns.   As an investor in a mortgage fund you own shares or units of a Mortgage Investment Corporation (MIC) or Mutual Fund Trust (Trust).   That MIC or Trust holds real mortgages registered on title of the subject property.   It is not uncommon to see returns of 6-10% consistently on these types of funds.   In addition, these investments can often be held within an RRSP, TFSA, RESP, or a variety of other registered investments vehicles, providing the fund has completed the necessary CRA registration.

In spite of all of these positive attributes, not every mortgage fund in Canada has been consistently successful and some have had catastrophic failures.   So how does an investor assess comparative risk from one fund to another?   What does the investor look for in a fund, to allow themselves the opportunity to take advantage of the strong returns, while also matching a conservative to moderate risk tolerance?

Below are some key questions one should ask when assessing a fund.

  1. Who is managing the fund?   Do the principals and Directors of the fund have a solid and experienced track record in mortgages, lending, investment, and real estate, as well as running a business?   The people responsible for the fund should have credentials in each of these areas to show that they can make sound decisions when managing a mortgage fund.
  1. Does the fund offer a guaranteed return?   To an investor this may seem like a positive thing for a fund to offer, but it’s not always as good as it seems.   Various economic and other market factors have potential to affect the returns to investors.   If a mortgage fund guarantees 10% to its investors and economic and market factors cause the fund to underperform, what happens?   In actuality, the fund has to either:
  1. Continue to pay 10% to the investor, which erodes the investor’s capital by reducing share value.

or

  1. Make up the loss the following year - which puts pressure on the fund to generate an unrealistic yield and may compromise sound lending parameters. 

Many funds have been sunk by guaranteeing a return.

  1. What are the overall underwriting policies?   Most lending decisions involves a complex cocktail of the following:
  1. LTV (loan to value) – this is the loan amount that the lender will lend divided by the value of the property.
  2. Lending area – large city, small city, rural etc.
  3. Property types –residential, commercial, multi family, single family, bare land, new construction.
  4. Loan size – maximum and minimum amounts.
  5. Rate – interest rates go up and down in relation to risk. 

The above factors must be considered but there are complexities to ensuring that the criteria make sense in the right scenario. The tight rope of providing a solid return while not overextending risk is a developed skill.   The success of this will boil down to who your fund’s management team, and if they possess the skills and experience to recognize the reactive correlations of the a-e factors listed above.

In Summary, mortgages represent an excellent high yield opportunity for any investor to participate in the real estate and mortgage market, and to obtain returns that will often beat public markets. 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT POSTS

Is Alternative Lending the Right Choice for Your Mortgage Needs?

By Sabeena Bubber • February 25, 2026
Alternative Lending in Canada: What It Is and When It Makes Sense Not everyone fits into the traditional lending box—and that’s where alternative mortgage lenders come in. Alternative lending refers to any mortgage solution that falls outside of the typical big bank offerings. These lenders are flexible, creative, and focused on helping Canadians who may not qualify for traditional financing still access the real estate market. Let’s explore when alternative lending might be the right fit for you. 1. You Have Damaged Credit Bad credit doesn’t have to mean your homeownership dreams are over. Many alternative lenders take a big-picture approach . While credit scores matter, they’ll also look at: Stable employment Consistent income Size of your down payment or existing equity If your credit has taken a hit but you can demonstrate strong income and savings—or have a solid explanation for past credit issues— an alternative lender may approve your mortgage when a bank won’t. Pro tip: Use an alternative mortgage as a short-term solution while you rebuild your credit, then refinance into a traditional mortgage with better terms down the line. 2. You're Self-Employed Being your own boss has its perks—but mortgage approval isn’t usually one of them. Traditional lenders require verifiable, consistent income—often two years’ worth. But self-employed Canadians typically write off significant expenses, reducing their declared income. Alternative lenders are more flexible and understanding of self-employed income structures. If your business is profitable and your personal finances are healthy, you may qualify even with lower stated income. Even if interest rates are slightly higher, this option is often worth it—especially when balanced against tax planning and business deductions . 3. You Earn Non-Traditional Income Today’s income sources aren’t always conventional. If you earn through: Airbnb rentals Tips and gratuities Rideshare or delivery apps (like Uber or Uber Eats) Commissions or contracts You might face challenges with traditional lenders. Alternative lenders are often more willing to work with these non-standard income streams , especially if the rest of your mortgage application is strong. Some will consider a shorter income history or evaluate your average earnings in a more flexible way. 4. You Need Expanded Debt-Service Ratios Canada’s mortgage stress test has made it harder for many borrowers to qualify with big banks. Alternative lenders can offer more generous debt-service ratio limits —meaning you might be able to qualify for a larger mortgage or a more suitable home, especially in competitive markets. While traditional GDS/TDS limits typically sit at 35/42 or 39/44 (depending on your credit), some alternative lenders will go higher, especially if: You have a larger down payment Your loan-to-value ratio is lower Your overall financial profile is strong It’s not a free-for-all—but it’s more flexible than bank lending. So, Is Alternative Lending Right for You? Alternative lending is designed to offer solutions when life doesn’t fit the traditional mold . Whether you're rebuilding credit, running your own business, or earning income in new ways, this path could help you get into a home sooner—or keep your current one. And here’s the key: You can only access alternative lenders through the mortgage broker channel . Let’s Explore Your Options Not sure where you fit? That’s okay. Every mortgage story is unique—and I’m here to help you write yours. If you’re curious about alternative mortgage products, want a second opinion, or need help getting approved, let’s talk . I’d be happy to help you explore the best solution for your situation. Reach out anytime. It would be a pleasure to work with you.

Start Smart: Get Pre-Approved for Your Mortgage

By Sabeena Bubber • February 18, 2026
Thinking of Buying a Home? Here’s Why Getting Pre-Approved Is Key If you’re ready to buy a home but aren’t sure where to begin, the answer is simple: start with a pre-approval. It’s one of the most important first steps in your home-buying journey—and here's why. Why a Pre-Approval is Crucial Imagine walking into a restaurant, hungry and excited to order, but unsure if your credit card will cover the bill. It’s the same situation with buying a home. You can browse listings online all day, but until you know how much you can afford, you’re just window shopping. Getting pre-approved for a mortgage is like finding out the price range you can comfortably shop within before you start looking at homes with a real estate agent. It sets you up for success and saves you from wasting time on properties that might be out of reach. What Exactly is a Pre-Approval? A pre-approval isn’t a guarantee. It’s not a promise that a lender will give you a mortgage no matter what happens with your finances. It’s more like a preview of your financial health, giving you a clear idea of how much you can borrow, based on the information you provide at the time. Think of it as a roadmap. After going through the pre-approval process, you’ll have a much clearer picture of what you can afford and what you need to do to make the final approval process smoother. What Happens During the Pre-Approval Process? When you apply for a pre-approval, lenders will look at a few key areas: Your income Your credit history Your assets and liabilities The property you’re interested in This comprehensive review will uncover any potential hurdles that could prevent you from securing financing later on. The earlier you identify these challenges, the better. Potential Issues a Pre-Approval Can Reveal Even if you feel confident that your finances are in good shape, a pre-approval might uncover issues you didn’t expect: Recent job changes or probation periods An income that’s heavily commission-based or reliant on extra shifts Errors or collections on your credit report Lack of a well-established credit history Insufficient funds saved for a down payment Existing debt reducing your qualification amount Any other financial blind spots you might not be aware of By addressing these issues early, you give yourself the best chance of securing the mortgage you need. A pre-approval makes sure there are no surprises along the way. Pre-Approval vs. Pre-Qualification: What’s the Difference? It’s important to understand that a pre-approval is more than just a quick online estimate. Unlike pre-qualification—which can sometimes be based on limited information and calculations—a pre-approval involves a thorough review of your finances. This includes looking at your credit report, providing detailed documents, and having a conversation with a mortgage professional about your options. Why Get Pre-Approved Now? The best time to secure a pre-approval is as soon as possible. The process is free and carries no risk—it just gives you a clear path forward. It’s never too early to start, and by doing so, you’ll be in a much stronger position when you're ready to make an offer on your dream home. Let’s Make Your Home Buying Journey Smooth A well-planned mortgage process can make all the difference in securing your home. If you’re ready to get pre-approved or just want to chat about your options, I’d love to help. Let’s make your home-buying experience a smooth and successful one!

Don’t Let Collections Derail Your Mortgage Application

By Sabeena Bubber • February 11, 2026
Can You Get a Mortgage If You Have Collections on Your Credit Report? Short answer? Not easily. Long answer? It depends—and it’s more common (and fixable) than you might think. When it comes to applying for a mortgage, your credit report tells lenders a story. Collections—debts that have been passed to a collection agency because they weren’t paid on time—are big red flags in that story. Regardless of how or why they got there, open collections are going to hurt your chances of getting approved. Let’s break this down. What Exactly Is a Collection? A collection appears on your credit report when a bill goes unpaid for long enough that the lender decides to stop chasing you—and hires a collection agency to do it instead. It doesn’t matter whether it was an unpaid phone bill, a forgotten credit card, or a disputed fine: to a lender, it signals risk. And lenders don’t like risk. Why It Matters to Mortgage Lenders? Lenders use your credit report to gauge how trustworthy you are with borrowed money. If they see you haven’t paid a past debt, especially recently, it suggests you might do the same with a new mortgage—and that’s enough to get your application denied. Even small collections can cause problems. A $32 unpaid utility bill might seem insignificant to you, but to a lender, it’s a red flag waving loudly. But What If I Didn’t Know About the Collection? It happens all the time. You move provinces and miss a final utility charge. Your cell provider sends a bill to an old address. Or maybe the collection is showing in error—credit reports aren’t perfect, and mistakes do happen. Regardless of the reason, the responsibility to resolve it still falls on you. Even if it’s an honest oversight or an error, lenders will expect you to clear it up or prove it’s been paid. And What If I Chose Not to Pay It? Some people intentionally leave certain collections unpaid—maybe they disagree with a charge, or feel a fine is unfair. Here are a few common “moral stand” collections: Disputed phone bills COVID-related fines Traffic tickets Unpaid spousal or child support While you might feel justified, lenders don’t take sides. They’re not interested in why a collection exists—only that it hasn’t been dealt with. And if it’s still active, that could be enough to derail your mortgage application. How Can You Find Out What’s On Your Report? Easy. You can check it yourself through services like Equifax or TransUnion, or you can work with a mortgage advisor to go through a full pre-approval. A pre-approval will quickly uncover any credit issues, including collections—giving you a chance to fix them before you apply for a mortgage. What To Do If You Have Collections Verify: Make sure the collection is accurate. Pay or Dispute: Settle the debt or begin a dispute process if it’s an error. Get Proof: Even if your credit report hasn’t updated yet, documentation showing the debt is paid can be enough for some lenders. Work With a Pro: A mortgage advisor can help you build a strategy and connect you with lenders who offer flexible solutions. Collections are common, but they can absolutely block your path to mortgage financing. Whether you knew about them or not, the best approach is to take action early. If you’d like to find out where you stand—or need help navigating your credit report—I’d be happy to help. Let’s make sure your next mortgage application has the best possible chance of approval.

LET'S TALK

SABEENA BUBBER

MORTGAGE BROKER | AMP

Contact Us