Private Mortgage Investing, What you need to know?  Is it for you?

Sabeena Bubber • November 21, 2016

This is a special article published to my blog, written by Dean Larson, COO of Northern Alliance Financial. If you have any questions, please contact me directly.  

Increasingly, Canadians are becoming more and more aware that traditional investments may not be their only or even best options anymore.   The average Canadian, particularly Gen Xers or Millennials, are less likely to blindly follow traditional investment advice from a bank, or even from that family friend, a financial planner, or insurance advisor.

The question is - what has changed?   Have people’s expectations changed?   Have investments changed?   Have our available options changed?   The answer to all of these is a resounding “YES!”   Historically, banks and insurance companies have created investment opportunities.   Consumer-focused investments included life insurance, bonds, mutual funds and other similar products with the object of providing neatly packaged, relatively conservative, accessible investments to the masses.

Today, the public has access to a myriad of investment options that would have once been relegated exclusively to very wealthy individuals or institutional investors.   One of these investment options is mortgage lending.

The mortgage market today can be divided primarily into the following categories:

‘Prime’ or ‘A’ Mortgages – These mortgages are for typical mortgage borrowers with good credit, regular employment and a down payment.   These low-rate mortgages are obtained primarily from banks, credit unions and monoline mortgage lenders (non bank lenders who are specifically in the mortgage business, and often funded by other big banks).

‘Alt A’ or ‘B’ Mortgages –.   These mortgages are designed for borrowers that fall just outside of standard mortgage qualification guidelines.   Some borrowers cannot prove self-employment income in standard ways, or provide non-standard down-payments, or have past credit blemishes. Institutional lenders and banks that are specifically focused on this type of lending typically have higher interest rates than ‘A’ lenders.

Private Mortgages – Private mortgages themselves can be divided up into two categories:

  1. Syndication / Direct mortgage- This is where an individual lends money to a specific borrower on a specific property.   The advantage to a lender is that they can dictate their return for that specific mortgage.   The disadvantage to the lender is that there are too many eggs in one basket, and if something goes wrong with that specific borrower or property, the individual that lent the money absorbs all the losses. Investment diversification is wise, even with mortgages.
  1. Mortgage Funds - These funds can take a variety of forms.   The technical term from a regulatory standpoint is “Mortgage Investment Entity”.   These funds can take form in a variety of structures such as   ‘mortgage investment corporation’, ‘mutual fund trust’, or even partnerships and corporations.   The differences between them largely have to do with regulatory and tax implications, although one could argue that a more regulated fund with greater checks and balances, further protects the investor. 

Advantages for an investor to invest through a fund rather than direct to the borrower include:

i) The investor’s money is in a pool with other investors and invested in a pool of mortgages.   So if a mortgage were to default and realize losses, the loss to fund is dispersed among the investors.   Typically a well-managed fund can have defaults without individual investors being aware, or suffering significant impact on their returns.

ii) The investor is not concerned about managing the investment, or regulatory issues.   The investor is not responsible for any reporting to the borrower, or any managing of defaults, or the payout of the mortgage.

So is it for me?   What’s the catch?   What’s the risk?

Mortgage funds create a great opportunity for an investor to earn consistent above-average returns.   As an investor in a mortgage fund you own shares or units of a Mortgage Investment Corporation (MIC) or Mutual Fund Trust (Trust).   That MIC or Trust holds real mortgages registered on title of the subject property.   It is not uncommon to see returns of 6-10% consistently on these types of funds.   In addition, these investments can often be held within an RRSP, TFSA, RESP, or a variety of other registered investments vehicles, providing the fund has completed the necessary CRA registration.

In spite of all of these positive attributes, not every mortgage fund in Canada has been consistently successful and some have had catastrophic failures.   So how does an investor assess comparative risk from one fund to another?   What does the investor look for in a fund, to allow themselves the opportunity to take advantage of the strong returns, while also matching a conservative to moderate risk tolerance?

Below are some key questions one should ask when assessing a fund.

  1. Who is managing the fund?   Do the principals and Directors of the fund have a solid and experienced track record in mortgages, lending, investment, and real estate, as well as running a business?   The people responsible for the fund should have credentials in each of these areas to show that they can make sound decisions when managing a mortgage fund.
  1. Does the fund offer a guaranteed return?   To an investor this may seem like a positive thing for a fund to offer, but it’s not always as good as it seems.   Various economic and other market factors have potential to affect the returns to investors.   If a mortgage fund guarantees 10% to its investors and economic and market factors cause the fund to underperform, what happens?   In actuality, the fund has to either:
  1. Continue to pay 10% to the investor, which erodes the investor’s capital by reducing share value.

or

  1. Make up the loss the following year - which puts pressure on the fund to generate an unrealistic yield and may compromise sound lending parameters. 

Many funds have been sunk by guaranteeing a return.

  1. What are the overall underwriting policies?   Most lending decisions involves a complex cocktail of the following:
  1. LTV (loan to value) – this is the loan amount that the lender will lend divided by the value of the property.
  2. Lending area – large city, small city, rural etc.
  3. Property types –residential, commercial, multi family, single family, bare land, new construction.
  4. Loan size – maximum and minimum amounts.
  5. Rate – interest rates go up and down in relation to risk. 

The above factors must be considered but there are complexities to ensuring that the criteria make sense in the right scenario. The tight rope of providing a solid return while not overextending risk is a developed skill.   The success of this will boil down to who your fund’s management team, and if they possess the skills and experience to recognize the reactive correlations of the a-e factors listed above.

In Summary, mortgages represent an excellent high yield opportunity for any investor to participate in the real estate and mortgage market, and to obtain returns that will often beat public markets. 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

RECENT POSTS

How to Finance Renovations When Buying a Home in Canada

By Sabeena Bubber • August 19, 2026
Can’t Find the Right Home After You’re Pre-Approved? There’s Another Option The best place to start any home purchase is with a mortgage pre-approval. It gives you clarity around your budget and lets you shop with confidence. But what happens when you’ve been pre-approved, you know where you want to live—and nothing suitable fits your price range? This is a common challenge, especially for first-time homebuyers. Before buyer fatigue sets in, it may be worth considering a different approach: buying a home that needs work and financing the renovations as part of your mortgage . What Is a Purchase Plus Improvements Mortgage? A purchase plus improvements program allows you to buy a property and include the cost of approved renovations directly in your mortgage. This can be a great solution if: You can’t find a move-in-ready home within budget You’re open to renovations You want to customize the home from the start It opens up more options and can help you get into a location or property that would otherwise be out of reach. How the Process Works While the idea is straightforward, the process itself is structured and requires planning. Here’s a high-level overview: Renovation quotes are required upfront You’ll need detailed quotes for the work you want completed before final mortgage approval. Renovations must add value The lender must be satisfied that the improvements will increase the property’s value accordingly. Funds are reimbursed, not advanced You pay for the renovations initially. Once the work is completed and verified by an appraiser, the lender reimburses you and adds the cost to your mortgage. With the right guidance, this process is very manageable—but it’s important to understand the steps before committing. Is This Program Right for You? Purchase plus improvements isn’t for everyone. Buying a home is already a big undertaking, and adding renovations can increase stress—especially if timelines, budgets, or contractors become challenging. That said, if you’re financially prepared and like the idea of shaping the home to fit your needs, this program can be an excellent way to get more value and flexibility from your purchase. Final Thoughts If you’re struggling to find the right home after being pre-approved, you may not need to lower your expectations—you may just need a different strategy. If you’d like to explore whether a purchase plus improvements mortgage makes sense for you, feel free to connect. I’d be happy to walk you through the process and outline exactly what this option would look like in your situation.

How Your Credit Score Impacts Mortgage Rates and Approval

By Sabeena Bubber • August 12, 2026
What Lenders Mean by “Good Credit” When You Apply for a Mortgage Credit is simply the ability to borrow money today based on the trust that you’ll repay it in the future. When you apply for a mortgage, lenders want proof that you’ve consistently honoured that trust by managing credit responsibly. But what does a good credit history actually look like to a lender? The 2 / 2 / 2 Rule Explained If you’re newer to credit or want a simple way to remember minimum mortgage credit requirements, think of the 2 / 2 / 2 rule: 2 active trade lines Established for at least 2 years With a minimum combined limit of $2,000 This is a common baseline lenders use when assessing credit for mortgage financing. What Counts as a Trade Line? A trade line is any account where credit is extended to you, such as: A credit card A line of credit A car loan A personal or installment loan Each trade line reports your payment history to the credit bureau and contributes to your credit score. For a trade line to be considered active , it must: Have been used at least once, and Show activity at least once every three months Why Time Matters Lenders want to see that you’ve managed credit responsibly over time , not just recently. Using two trade lines consistently for at least two years helps demonstrate stable financial habits and reliability. Understanding Credit Limits vs. Balances The credit limit is what matters—not the balance. For example: A $1,000 credit card + a $2,500 line of credit = $3,500 total limit This meets the minimum requirement You do not need to carry a balance to build credit. In fact, the best approach is to: Use your credit regularly Pay it off in full each month (for credit cards) Make all loan payments on time If your lender offers a credit limit increase and you’re managing credit well, it’s often a good idea to accept it. Higher limits—used responsibly—can strengthen your credit profile. A Simple Way to Build Credit Automatically One effective strategy is to: Put recurring bills on your credit card Set up an automatic transfer to pay the balance in full every month Automation helps build positive credit history without requiring constant attention—just be sure to monitor your accounts to ensure everything runs smoothly. What About Credit Scores? Yes, credit scores matter—but they’re not the whole story. If you: Have two active trade lines Established for two years With at least $2,000 in total limits And no missed payments …your credit score will generally take care of itself. That said, it’s still wise to review your credit report occasionally to check for errors or unfamiliar accounts. Final Thoughts If you’re thinking about buying a home in the next couple of years, now is the perfect time to review your credit and make sure you’re on track. Small adjustments today can make a big difference when it’s time to apply for a mortgage. If you’d like help reviewing your credit or understanding how it affects your mortgage options, feel free to connect anytime. I’d be happy to walk through it with you and help you plan with confidence.

What Is a Cashback Mortgage and How Does It Work?

By Sabeena Bubber • August 5, 2026
Cashback Mortgages: Are They Worth It? Here’s What You Need to Know If you’ve been exploring mortgage options and come across the term cashback mortgage , you might be wondering what exactly it means—and whether it’s a smart move. Let’s break it down in simple terms. What Is a Cashback Mortgage? A cashback mortgage is just like a regular mortgage—but with one extra feature: you receive a lump sum of cash when the mortgage closes . This cash is typically: A fixed amount , or A percentage of the total mortgage , usually between 1% and 7% , depending on your mortgage term and lender. The money is tax-free and paid directly to you on closing day. What Can You Use the Cashback For? There are no restrictions on how you use the funds. Here are some common uses: Covering closing costs Buying new furniture Renovations or home upgrades Paying off high-interest debt Boosting your cashflow during a tight transition Whether it’s to help you settle in or catch up financially, cashback can offer a helpful buffer— but it comes at a cost . The True Cost of a Cashback Mortgage Here’s the part many people overlook: cashback mortgages come with higher interest rates than standard mortgages. Why? Because the lender is essentially advancing you a small loan upfront—and they’re going to make that money back (and then some) through your mortgage payments. So while the upfront cash feels like a bonus, you’ll pay more in interest over time to have that convenience. Breaking Down the Numbers It’s hard to give a blanket answer about how much more you’ll pay since it depends on: Your interest rate The cashback amount The mortgage term Your payment schedule This is why it’s important to run the numbers with a mortgage professional who can help you compare this option with others based on your personal financial situation. Are You Eligible for a Cashback Mortgage? Not everyone qualifies. Cashback mortgages generally come with stricter requirements . Lenders often want to see: Excellent credit history Strong, stable income Low debt-to-income ratio If your mortgage file includes anything “outside the box”—like being self-employed or recently changing jobs—qualifying for a cashback mortgage might be tough. What If You Need to Break the Mortgage? This is one of the biggest risks with cashback mortgages. If your circumstances change and you need to break your mortgage early, you could be on the hook for: Paying back some or all of the cashback you received, and A prepayment penalty (typically the interest rate differential or 3 months’ interest—whichever is higher) That can be a very expensive combination. So if there’s even a chance you might need to sell, refinance, or move before your term is up, a cashback mortgage might not be the best fit. Should You Consider a Cashback Mortgage? Maybe—but only with eyes wide open. Cashback mortgages can be helpful in the right scenario, but they’re not free money. They’re a lending tool that benefits the lender , and the key is knowing exactly what you’re agreeing to. Final Thoughts: Talk to an Expert First Choosing the right mortgage isn’t just about the lowest rate or the biggest perk—it’s about making a choice that fits your whole financial picture. If you’re considering a cashback mortgage, or just want to explore all your options, let’s talk. As an independent mortgage professional , I can help you weigh the pros and cons of various products, so you can make a confident, informed decision. Have questions? I’d be happy to help—reach out anytime.